Most people focus on the crust and toppings when it comes to pizza, but the cheese is just as important. Choosing the Best Cheese for Your Pizza can make or break your pizza. It affects not just the flavor but also the texture, reliability, and overall experience of each bite.
Mozzarella stands as the number one cheese choice for pizza production despite the existence of multiple cheese options. Choosing the Best Cheese for Your Pizza starts with understanding different types of mozzarella. The final pizza outcome depends heavily on selecting between fresh mozzarella and low-moisture mozzarella.
I will explain various mozzarella types as well as their melting characteristics before determining which selection is optimal for a specific pizza type. Additionally, I will discuss Choosing the Best Cheese for Your Pizza and provide important advice about dealing with and handling mozzarella storage alongside recommendations to maximize your cheese enjoyment.
Table of Contents
Choosing the Best Cheese for Your Pizza: Fresh Mozzarella vs. Low-Moisture Mozzarella
The two main types of mozzarella exist as fresh mozzarella and low-moisture mozzarella. Choosing the Best Cheese for Your Pizza will determine how your final product turns out, as your pizza outcome will shift based on the different forms of mozzarella cheese.
1. Fresh Mozzarella
The fresh mozzarella type of cheese exists as a white soft product that contains significant water quantities. It’s usually sold in water-filled containers or vacuum-sealed packaging. This cheese is traditionally used in Neapolitan and Margherita pizzas because of its creamy texture and mild, milky flavor.
Characteristics of Fresh Mozzarella:
✅ Soft and moist with a delicate flavor
✅ Melts beautifully at high temperatures
✅ Best for traditional wood-fired pizzas
✅ Needs to be drained properly before use
The biggest drawback? It releases a lot of moisture when melted, which can make your pizza soggy if not prepared correctly.
2. Low-moisture mozzarella
Low-moisture mozzarella contains less water than its fresh counterpart because of its name. The block-shaped or pre-shredded version of this cheese selects New York-style and Chicago deep-dish pizza makers.
Characteristics of Low-Moisture Mozzarella:
This cheese variety maintains a firm texture because it distributes heat evenly while producing minimal moisture leakage.
✅ Offers a more pronounced, slightly salty flavor
✅ The signature gooey cheese pull in pizzas forms when using this cheese.
✅ Best for oven-baked pizzas with long cook times
✅ The low moisture content in low-moisture mozzarella helps prevent pizza sogginess. Traditional mozzarella provides a fresher and creamier taste than low-moisture mozzarella does.
Which Mozzarella is Best for Different Pizza Styles?
The selection of mozzarella needs to match the style of pizza you intend to prepare because different pizza types require unique types of cheese. The selection of mozzarella depends on the specific pizza style you want to create according to the following guidelines:
Neapolitan & Margherita Pizza
Best choice: Fresh mozzarella
Why? Fresh mozzarella pairs perfectly with this pizza since it demands a simple combination of thin crust combined with tangy tomato sauce and high-quality fresh mozzarella. In wood-fired oven baking fresh mozzarella transforms into a smooth layer that unites perfectly with other pizza ingredients.
Fresh mozzarella requires thin cuts before resting on a paper towel for 15 minutes to extract moisture.
New York-Style Pizza
Best choice: Low-moisture mozzarella
Why? Typical New York pizza features a crispy-foldable crust that provides harmonious texture between crunchy and chewy. The definite characteristics of low-moisture mozzarella include its ability to spread uniformly which produces stretchable cheese without damaging pizza slices.
The best technique for using low-moisture mozzarella in your pizza is to purchase a block and shred it yourself to achieve better taste and melt.
Chicago Deep-Dish Pizza
Best choice: Low-moisture mozzarella
Why? The distinctive characteristic of Chicago-style pizza includes its substantial crust together with multiple layers of toppings and cheese. The low moisture content in mozzarella cheese enables pizza structure preservation and produces a deep layer of cheese that stays firm throughout the extended baking period.
To prevent cheese burning during extended baking time, place it under the sauce.
Homemade Oven-Baked Pizza
Best choice: A mix of low-moisture and fresh mozzarella
Why? Using both fresh and low-moisture mozzarella allows you to achieve peak flavor together with ideal texture because fresh mozzarella brings creaminess while low-moisture mozzarella provides excellent melting capabilities.
Expert Tips for Using Mozzarella on Pizza
1. How to Properly Drain Fresh Mozzarella
Pat the cheese dry with a paper towel before adding it to your pizza.
For extra moisture removal, slice and let it sit on a rack for 30 minutes.
2. Shredding vs. Slicing: Which is Better?
Slicing fresh mozzarella gives a traditional look and ensures even melting.
Shredding low-moisture mozzarella creates better coverage and gives that classic cheese stretch.
3. Store Cheese Properly for Freshness
Fresh mozzarella: Keep it in its original liquid in the fridge and use it within 3-4 days.
Low-moisture mozzarella: Store in an airtight container and refrigerate for up to two weeks.
Freezing tip: You can freeze low-moisture mozzarella for up to 3 months, but fresh mozzarella doesn’t freeze well as it alters the texture.
How Mozzarella is Made (Brief Overview)
Mozzarella is traditionally made from cow’s milk or buffalo milk, using a special process called pasta filata. This involves stretching and kneading the curds until they form the signature smooth, elastic texture. Fresh mozzarella is then stored in water, while low-moisture mozzarella is aged and dried for a firmer consistency.
Final Thoughts: Which Mozzarella is Right for You?
Choosing the right mozzarella depends on the style of pizza you’re making and your personal preferences. If you love authentic Italian flavors, go for fresh mozzarella. If you prefer classic, gooey pizza, low-moisture mozzarella is your best bet.
Why not experiment with different types and see which one you love best? The beauty of pizza is that you can customize it to your liking! Whether you prefer the creaminess of fresh mozzarella or the golden-brown melt of low moisture, one thing is certain—great cheese makes a great pizza!
What’s your favorite mozzarella for pizza? Let us know in the comments below!
Related Articles
Domino’s Brooklyn Style vs. Hand Tossed Pizza
The Magic of Trader Joe’s Pizza Dough
No.1: Perfect New Haven Style Pizza Recipe
Can You Put Mascarpone on Pizza?
Samina Suppra is a distinguished professional with a Ph.D. in Management Sciences, seamlessly integrating her academic expertise with a vibrant career in writing and content creation. As an accomplished web blogger, content writer, and creative writer, she offers a multifaceted perspective, drawing from her extensive research background and practical experiences.
In addition to her scholarly pursuits, Samina Suppra is a passionate cooking expert, sharing her culinary expertise through a popular series of cooking blogs. Her love for cooking and household management enriches her writing, offering readers both practical advice and delicious recipes that cater to a variety of tastes.
